Monday, November 6, 2023

There's A Lot At Stake

 Article printed this week's edition of Lehovin newspaper 
THERE’S A LOT AT STAKE

Avi Schnall has thrown his hat into the ring to represent Lakewood in the New Jersey Assembly. As the Asbury Park Press reported, “Schnall, a powerful leader in the township’s Orthodox community, jumped into the race for the 30thAssembly District just weeks ago, a move observers saw as a way to boost the Jewish community’s voice in Trenton.”
“I think there are enough people in the district who know who I am,” Schnall, who served as director of the New Jersey office of Agudath Israel of America in Lakewood, said at the time. “I have accomplished a lot and people will vote for results.” 

[Ed.: The only results important to the Yeshivaleit in Lakewood, are those which help maintain Torah values and practice.
Money is nice, but, it doesn’t mean that much to bnei Torah.]

 There’s plenty to fight for in Trenton. Toeiva issues, murder under the guise of kindness, and religious freedom just to name a few. The money is tempting. 

[Ed.: But, Lakewood’s Bnei Torah care way more about their children’s ruchniyus than about their pocketbooks. Somehow, even if with financial difficulty, Lakewood’s yeshivos and Bais Yaakovs are not only surviving, but thriving, bursting at the seams. And people think that the Olam HaTorah will sell their children’s ruchniyus and Klal Yisroel’s future with the naivete of thinking that ‘we’ll get the money and there’ll be no strings attached?’]

Read what Mr. Schnall wrote about it, himself, not long ago. “We’ve never advocated for funding that directly covers the Standard educational programs that our schools provide.
There’s always a catch. If the state is funding something, they may then decide to regulate how it is being provided. If they cover the costs of the instructions, they can tell us what to teach and how to teach it and who can teach it. Is it a risk we’re willing to take?”

[Ed.: NO. It is definitely not a risk we should be willing to take. Administrators and
baalei batim might look at school vouchers as a tremendous help to alleviate the financial burden, but Lakewood hasn’t spent decades building the Town of Torah to now give
it all away. The Bnei Torah will never give up their children for a n’zid adashim.]

We share with you some of what New Jersey is currently telling their teachers and schools, to enlighten the Lehovin readership a bit about what’s at stake. In 2019 Governor Murphy “signed a law that would require the state public schools to implement [toeiva] curriculum for students in grades five through 12, becoming the second U.S. state to do so after California.

Last week, the New Jersey Department of Education released documents clarifying its
role in implementing the curriculum. The document stated that by the end of
second-grade students are expected to “discuss the range of ways people express their
gender and how gender-role stereotypes may limit behavior.” 

[Ed.: By the end of SECOND GRADE. The requirements by the end of fifth grade cannot even be cleaned up to be printed in this, or any, newspaper. There is no way that any caring yungerman or Jewish mother
can tolerate even the possibility of the state of New Jersey getting anywhere close to our
preschools, yeshivos or Bais Yaakovs.] 

For those who think they don’t care to change the education of the Haredim in Lakewood, think again. Five years ago, the Asbury Park Press printed an interview with Naftuli Moster of YAFFED titled Should state oversee private schools? The end of the article reads: “Will Moster be bringing his campaign to Lakewood? Yes, he says. … But for now, he wants to focus on New York. Last week, city education officials say
their investigation into whether Hasidic schools were complying with the state’s “substantially equivalent” standard for non-public schools was being hindered by the refusal of some schools to allow investigators to enter the schools or to provide more than a basic outline of the curriculum. Moster believes he eventually will prevail. And when he does, he will turn his attention to New Jersey. Gov. Phil Murphy and the Legislature should be prepared. State standards should be developed that ensure all students in New Jersey — public and private — are provided a thorough and efficient education. The state should establish minimum curricular requirements and, insist, as a condition of any state funding, that they are
being met.” Forewarned is forearmed. Let no one be fooled, naïve, or bought off.

[Ed.: And, let no one – not a single yungerman, aishes chayil, or caring yerei Shomayim- sit idly by or complacent and let anyone, even with the best intentions or bags full of money, even put their eyes on our children, or have the slightest foothohold on our most precious possessions.]

13 comments:

  1. There may be problems with the Schnall candidacy, but Lehovin constantly makes the same mistake.

    Money for Yeshivos isn't gashmiyus. Money for Chadarim isn't treif. The idea that being irresponsible about money is the Torah way is not דרכי אבותינו ורבותינו. The Gedolei Yisroel in Eretz Yisroel knew about the possibility of the government involving themselves in the Chinuch. Yet they invested much political capital to fund schools and Chadarim. They told people to vote and told them that not voting is a terrible aveira.

    Voting for money for Yeshivos is no different to voting for Yeshivos to stay open. The zilzul in money shows an unserious attitude to the issues.

    I am not saying what to do lemaaseh, that is above my, and the newspaper editor's, paygrade.

    ReplyDelete
  2. All these Ed. notes are shtusim. They pretend that the Republicans will win if only we vote for Thompson. Wrong. NJ is Democrat, and it is highly unlikely that this will chnge anytime soon. In the meantime, Schnall can advocate on all our needs, not just money. What to do Lema'aseh is not above my pay grade. It is to listen to the Moetzes, the Roshei Yeshiva, and other Gedolim who say to vote for Schnall. .

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. As usual.You're behind.
      Check up secular sites eg. NJ.com
      The GOP had momentum. With possibility of sweeping into Assenlby majority.
      It has though been somewhat recently stymied.. with this Schnall ploy
      The Democrat puppeteers & Murphy long grasp frum Jews have influence all way out of proportion
      They're operating according
      Eh,who are the groisse leaders directing Who?

      Delete
  3. As a long time participant and adherent to Agudah/Moetzes, I want to update Klal Yisroel to the current status Agudah/Moetzes.

    It's all for the Agudah convention that draws thousands of people and enables many speakers to participate as a freebie for a nice extended Shabbos retreat.

    I and many others stopped participating in their conventions.

    Now we reached a plateau, where a member of Aguda/Moetzes calls "Korach", others that disagree with their agenda decisions, We are discontinuing following anything coming out of that group.

    It's not based on our Torah Mi'sinai's Mesorah.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I'm not ch'v saying or implying against the Talmidey Chachomim who are saying that Daas Torah is to support Schnall. Kvodom bemokomey munach. However being that there is such a strong campaign to convince us that who you vote for needs to follow DaasTorah, it is important to note that Rav Moshe Feinstein felt otherwise. See hakdoma to Igros Moshe chelek 8 page 27 where it says he refused to endorse political candidates, opposed Gedoley Torah getting involved in political decisions and that he used to say that Gadlus in Torah does not guarantee political acumen. This is not ch'v meant to criticize or disagree with the Talmidey Chachomim who support Schnall. Perhaps Rav Moshe was a daas yochid. But when we are hearing so much about Daas Torah and who to vote for, let us not think the opinion of Rav Moshe does not exist. Or is just Daas Baaley Batim.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. But If the Gedolim got involved, does R’ Moshe still say to do as you please?

      Delete
    2. So the goal post has moved from no gedolim endorsing Schnall to gedolim don’t have a right to endorse..

      Delete
    3. So the goalpost has moved back to original definition of gedolim
      & how they come to their accoutrements

      Delete
    4. Close relatives of several of those instructing how to vote were strongly firmly told against taking visas & going to Kobe, Japan.
      They went anyway, yes?

      Delete
    5. Kobe was told strongly firmly not to get on the helicopter in bad weather. he went anyway, yes?

      Delete
    6. Ignorant tipush- par obviously for the crowd,

      They Escaped to Japan,later to America.
      DT never stopped them .
      Somehow though yet of significantly lesser level they're entitled to tell others?

      Delete
    7. Mr. Cohen, well, apparently they were right then, so they must be right again today!

      Delete
    8. The manhigei hador were allowed to be ignored !?They were wrong then?!

      Delete