The question many are asking is this beginning of the end for the frum WhatsApp community?
What was considered a clean and safe
Messaging app for the frum community has now changed as WhatsApp shifts to be like all social media by adding a channels feature with a global search option like other apps such as telegram. Over the next few days this feature will be available to all Whatsapp users.
Messaging app for the frum community has now changed as WhatsApp shifts to be like all social media by adding a channels feature with a global search option like other apps such as telegram. Over the next few days this feature will be available to all Whatsapp users.
The company announced "we’re excited to launch WhatsApp Channels to over 150 countries and deliver a private way to receive updates that matter to you. We’re welcoming thousands of organizations, sports teams, artists, and thought leaders that people can follow, right within WhatsApp".
What is the problem?
Whatsapp used to be a clean and simple app but now it's getting disgusting with the ability to search for and join channels with shmutz and filth. You can't as of now op out or delete this new function. Kosher phone filter companies are facing an uphill battle trying to find a solution to block or disable the channels feature. Tech Industry are calling on users to contact whatsapp directly and letting them know how the new channels is a danger to our community. Others are suggesting leaving and going to other messaging apps such as Signal.
An article on LinkedIn by the ceo of safetelecom:
The introduction of this feature presents a significant challenge for the Orthodox Jewish community and communities with similar values and sensitivities. Traditionally, WhatsApp has served as a reliable platform for simple and private communication among community members, allowing them to maintain a digital space in line with their cultural and religious values.
However, the advent of "Channels" introduces an element of unpredictability and exposure to potentially offensive content. This feature enables unknown individuals and entities to broadcast messages and content to a wider audience, regardless of personal connections or shared contact numbers. As a result, community members may find themselves inadvertently exposed to content that contradicts their traditional values and religious principles.
Furthermore, parents within these communities may be concerned about the impact of this exposure on their children, whom they are diligently raising with a strong adherence to their cultural and religious values. The ability for children to easily access and encounter undesirable content on WhatsApp Channels is a genuine concern for parents striving to provide a safe and culturally appropriate digital environment for their families.
Safetelecom says out they are working on a solutuon that has the ability to block key functionalities related to WhatsApp Channels on select Pixel devices. This update will enable users to: Block Channel Discovery: Prevent the ability to search for new channels, ensuring a more controlled content environment. Block Channel Viewing: Restrict access to view channel content, allowing users avoid viewing objectionable content. Block Channel Following: Limit the ability to follow channels, offering a higher degree of content control.
However there still remains no solution for most users and industry techs say any channel that is followed by an account before switching to a kosher phone may not be blocked in the future as of now.
TAG already has solutions for Android devices. Mb Smart, Netspark, and Gentech all have blocks for Android.
ReplyDeleteDo these solutions allow whatsapp and block channels or block whatsapp entirely?
DeleteThese allow you to have whatsapp but not channels. The best one is probably Netspark.
DeleteMB Smart also has a good block. And it is a fraction of the price. Gentech is over 100 a year and they are 30 a year. Highly recommended if you are not using a browser.
DeleteYou can also get a Talk n Tech device without Whatsapp at www.thesafecell.com
ReplyDeleteI installed an older version of WhatsApp (from a month ago) as an APK and disabled auto updates. I don't have channels now.
ReplyDeleteHow do you download the old version?
DeleteIt won't help you as they force you to update after a week or two one the new version is out.
DeleteWhatsapp was bought by Facebook for 20 billion dollars. This was bound to happen. Time to move away from it.
DeleteThe big problem is on iOS ! There is no solution :(
ReplyDeleteWhat’s up with WhatsApp?
ReplyDeleteby Y.E.K
WhatsApp began as a simple messaging app aiming to bridge the communication gap between countries. It gained immense popularity, and after becoming a global go-to app, it was acquired in 2014 by Facebook for $20 billion. Subsequently, it began evolving, albeit slowly, to align with Facebook’s integration goals.
Mark Zuckerberg, the CEO of Facebook, while discussing the acquisition of WhatsApp, emphasized their efforts to help WhatsApp expand beyond just messaging. He specifically highlighted the “stories” feature, which lets users share posts with their contacts (sounds a lot like Facebook, doesn’t it?). Recently, WhatsApp introduced “channels,” furthering their integration vision. This feature is promoted as a platform for following celebrities and other interests, essentially embedding a social media aspect within WhatsApp.
While some filtering companies have been trying to block this new feature (with varying levels of success), which is obviously very important, this situation should give us pause. It is clear that we’re at a juncture where we must ask ourselves: Would we use a social media app just for messaging? Would we start using this app if it were newly released today? Should we continue using this app, given its current trajectory? These are points to ponder as we realize we have slowly been entangled in this web. At this point, maybe we should just delete it?
While there are many legitimate uses for WhatsApp, it unfortunately often ends up being used for joining many groups. The risk in these groups is real. The level of yiras shomayim of a group is only as strong as the weakest person in the group.
Other communication alternatives can be explored for business settings, such as Slack, Teams, and similar products. These apps cater to a business perspective and have excellent integrations.
PS The Tzadikkim at TAG, and the filtering companies are working on solutions. iOS sticks out as an issue thought that will hopefully be sorted iy"H.