Monday, March 25, 2019

Assisted Suicide Bill Approved, Murphy says will sign it

Earlier today both the state assembly and Senate in NJ voted to approve "the medical aid in dying for the Terminally I'll Act" and governor Phill Murphy said he will sign it into law. Opponents argued there is no way for a doctor to determine when most people are going to die. Rabbonim have issued a psak calling it Shefichas Domim.

 The bill contains numerous safeguards and procedures to ensure the integrity and safety of the process, including:



 A patient must have a prognosis of six months or less to live in order to request and be prescribed medication under the bill. The bill defines a “terminal disease” as an irreversible disease that has been medically confirmed and will result in a patient’s death within six months.

 It would cover: 1) an adult resident of New Jersey; 2) who is capable and has been determined by the patient’s attending physician and consulting physician to be suffering from a terminal disease; and 3) has voluntarily expressed a wish to die.

 The bill would require patients suffering from a terminal disease to first verbally request a prescription from their attending physician, followed by a second verbal request at least 15 days later.

 The attending physician would have to offer the patient a chance to rescind the request. A consulting physician would then be called upon to certify the original diagnosis and reaffirm the patient is capable of making a decision. It would also require one request in writing signed by two witnesses.

 A valid request for medication must be signed and dated by the patient and witnessed by at least two individuals who, in the patient’s presence, attest that the patient is capable and is acting voluntarily to sign the request.

 Only patients would be permitted to administer the drug to themselves. At least one of the witnesses must be a person who is not: 1) a relative of the patient; 2) entitled to any portion of the estate of the patient; 3) an owner, operator, or employee of a health care facility where the patient is receiving treatment, or 4) the patient’s physician.

 The bill requires that the patient’s attending physician recommend that the patient participate in a consultation concerning additional treatment opportunities, palliative care, comfort care, hospice care and pain control options, and provide the patient with a referral to a health care professional qualified to discuss these options.

 The attending physician would be required to document the recommendation in the patient’s medical record, and indicate whether the patient chose to participate in the consultation and whether the patient is receiving palliative, comfort or hospice care.

11 comments:

  1. No statement from Agudah of NJ?
    Total silence!

    ReplyDelete
  2. I did not hear or see any co-ordinated effort by the gedolim with regard to this issue. A Yom Tefilah, perhaps? No word from any askonim or anybody.
    Why not???

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. you answered the question yourself, because its not nec. what exactly bothers you about this bill ? dont scream !!

      Delete
    2. HUH?
      Refuah Shlaima to your Neshoma

      Delete

    3. The Magic Word is "Murder".


      Maybe some desire Orwellian doublespeak, but we do not!

      Does they have a hand in shortening someone else's life?!


      Why did we fight the Cold War?!
      If life doesn't have a value beyond all then the difference between us and the Communists is just a difference in degree!
      Hospitals have, until now, been looked upon as a place of refuge. Are you prepared for them to be turned into actuarial bureaus,as is happening in other countries, deciding how much value to allot each person?!
      Are you prepared for seismic change?!

      Delete
    4. maybe i'm missing something, are you against the idea of a terminally ill patient choosing to say he had enough? it makes perfect sense ( it is the torah that demands a yid think otherwise ) but the torah does not say interfere with umas haolam doing as they please. what do u see as the ramifications to us yidden

      Delete
    5. Even if you were correct in principle (you are not) this bill will endanger everyone’s life. Insurance companies will no longer cover things they used to. Furthermore the lack of safeguards in this bill is astonishing. They actually voted to make it easier to murder a patient with OUT their approval . For example they specifically allowed nursing home owners to be witnesses that their patient wants to die! This bill is murderous even if I agreed with your anti Torah ideology.

      Delete
    6. nursing home owners WANT their patients kept alive so they can bill - no owners are signing anything ! insurance companies not paying is an ongoing issue separate from this bill

      Delete
    7. 1. If the patient has lousy reimbursements, and they need the bed for someone else who has a great reimbursements.

      2. A separate issue that is directly effected by what other options there are. Where ever assisted suicide has been legalized, insurance companies stop covering things they used to. This has also been true of medicare/medicaid

      Delete
  3. the bill has no safeguards, this bill was weakened tremendously making it easier to kill off patients who don't want to die.

    list of kosher aidim that a patient want to die include medical insurance companies, life insurance beneficiaries, and owners of nursing homes for patients in the nursing home.

    ReplyDelete



  4. As usual
    Fiddling while the world burns

    ReplyDelete